Europe Needs to Move Away from More Public Service Obligations for Long-Distance Rail

Brussels, 31 October 2023

  • To create new demand for long-distance rail, Europe needs to move away from prescribed and subsidised Public Service Obligations (PSOs).
  • Instead, for the sake of the EU Green Deal, EU Member States should create conditions for more commercial services that are proven to grow revenues, reduce subsidy and speed up modal shift to rail.

PSO concession contracts in long-distance rail are meant to ensure there are certain services and frequencies, creating a rail product that authorities think the passengers will want.

However, in the many cases where no market analysis has taken place, they both underserve the market at times and overserve it at others.

With the rigid inflexible nature of PSOs, demand is not optimally served nor are frequencies as high as they could be. All in all, there is little opportunity to grow long-distance rail.

The latest EU Rail Market Monitoring Report (RMMS) confirms this: While PSOs saw a 6 percentage point jump from 2018-2020, the overall modal split of passenger rail inched up only 0.45 percentage points between 2015-2019, showing that PSOs are simply too slow and expensive.

It is understandable if governments want to spend money on encouraging more long-distance passenger rail, but PSOs are the wrong vehicle. Instead, Member States should do so in a manner that creates fast growth, namely:

  • Non-discriminatory access to long-distance rolling stock for commercially driven services – and its financing, both new and second-hand,
  • Lower track access charges, decreased to the level of direct cost,
  • Mandated full transparency: All Rail Tickets on Sale at All Rail Ticket Vendors.

“As we can see from the RMMS Report – and the current example of incumbent SBB CFF FFS in Switzerland – demanding more and more PSO subsidy without any improvement has become part of the dominant rail operators’ DNA. 

Instead, passenger rail operators must be careful with taxpayer money. Not only will commercially-driven services shoulder this responsibility, but they will also grow the long-distance rail market much faster than any PSO concession contract“

ALLRAIL Secretary General Nick Brooks